top of page
Writer's pictureEmily Groben

What To Do When a Child Disobeys - A BCBA's Guide for Parents

Updated: Nov 26, 2024

As a parent, it’s inevitable that you’ll encounter moments when your child disobeys you. Whether it’s refusing to follow instructions, throwing a tantrum, or ignoring your requests, disobedience can be frustrating. However, it’s important to understand that disobedience is a form of communication. Your child may be expressing discomfort, testing boundaries, or simply not understanding how to follow through with a task. As a Board Certified Behavior Analyst (BCBA), I want to share effective strategies to manage and address disobedience using principles from Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA).


1. Stay Calm and Avoid Reacting Emotionally

When your child disobeys, it’s easy to feel upset or frustrated. However, your response is crucial. If you react with anger or frustration, it may escalate the situation and make it harder to resolve. Instead, take a deep breath and remain calm. A calm, neutral tone will help your child focus on the next steps rather than on your emotional response.

2. Understand the Function of the Behavior

In ABA, we believe that all behavior serves a function. Your child’s disobedience may be happening for a variety of reasons, including:

  • Attention: They may be seeking attention or a reaction from you.

  • Escape: They may want to avoid a specific task or activity.

  • Access to Tangibles: They may be asking for a toy, a treat, or something they want.

  • Sensory Needs: They may be feeling overwhelmed or overstimulated.

Understanding why your child is disobeying will help you choose the best response. For example, if your child is refusing to do their homework (escape behavior), the solution may be to break the task into smaller, manageable steps.

3. Use Clear, Simple Instructions

Sometimes children disobey because they don’t understand what is being asked of them. Be sure to give clear, concise, and specific instructions. Instead of saying, "Clean your room," try something more specific, like "Please pick up all the toys from the floor." This helps your child know exactly what is expected.

4. Reinforce Positive Behavior

Reinforcement is key in ABA. When your child follows instructions or behaves well, be sure to provide positive reinforcement, such as praise, a small reward, or extra playtime. Reinforcing positive behavior makes it more likely that your child will comply in the future.

For example, if your child picks up their toys without being asked, say, "Great job picking up your toys! You can have 10 more minutes of screen time." Positive reinforcement encourages your child to repeat the desired behavior.

5. Set Clear and Consistent Expectations

Consistency is essential when addressing disobedience. Establish clear rules and expectations, and be sure to follow through each time. If you say, "It’s time for bed," make sure you’re consistent in enforcing bedtime. Children thrive on routine and knowing what to expect, and consistent expectations help eliminate confusion.

6. Use First/Then Language

First/Then language is an effective strategy in ABA to help children transition between tasks and manage expectations. It provides clear structure and helps children understand what’s expected before they get to do something they want. For example, "First we finish your homework, then you can play with your toys."

This reduces the likelihood of disobedience because your child knows that completing a task will lead to something they enjoy. The “First” part gives them a clear goal, and the “Then” part motivates them to follow through.

7. Offer Choices

Giving your child a sense of control can reduce disobedience, especially if they are resisting a particular task. Offer two choices that are both acceptable to you. For example, instead of saying, "Put your shoes on," say, "Do you want to wear the red shoes or the blue shoes?" Offering choices helps children feel empowered, which can reduce resistance.

8. Use Time-Outs Effectively

If your child continues to disobey after you’ve used other strategies, a time-out may be necessary to give them a break and help them regain self-control. Keep in mind that time-outs should be used as a way to calm down and reflect, not as a punishment. Choose a quiet space for your child to calm down for a few minutes, and make sure they understand why they’re being given a break.

9. Stay Patient and Consistent

Change takes time. It’s important to be patient with your child as they learn new behaviors. Be consistent with your expectations and reinforcement, and remember that disobedience is often a sign that your child is still learning how to navigate different situations. With time and support, your child will begin to understand what behaviors are expected and learn to follow through.

10. Seek Support if Needed

If your child’s disobedience is persistent and you’re struggling to manage the behavior, don’t hesitate to seek support from a BCBA or a professional specializing in behavior management. A behavior analyst can help assess the behavior, identify its function, and provide tailored strategies that work for your child.


Disobedience is a common challenge for parents, but it doesn’t have to be a battle. By staying calm, understanding the function of the behavior, reinforcing positive actions, and setting clear expectations, you can help guide your child toward better behavior. Remember, it’s all about consistency, patience, and positive reinforcement. And if you need support along the way, professionals like BCBAs are here to help.

Parenting can be tough, but with the right tools and strategies, you’ll be better equipped to navigate these challenges and foster positive, cooperative behaviors in your child.


Instagram: @emilygroben

2 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Questions I get asked about potty training

1. Where to start with potty training To start potty training, it’s important to track your child’s progress. You can do this by...

Why do toddlers bite?

1. Why do toddlers bite Toddlers bite for a variety of reasons, often as a way to express frustration, discomfort, or a need for...

Comments


bottom of page